Are Bike Gloves Better With or Without Fingers?

Are Bike Gloves Better With or Without Fingers?

I know it, you love hitting the open road on your bike.

But you also know that a good pair of cycling gloves can make all the difference when it comes to comfort and performance.

As a long-time bike rider, I’ve tried my share of gloves and have often wondered – are bike gloves better with fingers or without?

In this article, I’ll share my experiences and recommendations to help you decide which type of cycling gloves are right for you.

Whether you’re a casual rider or a hardcore racer, gloves play an important role in protecting your hands and improving your grip.

Let’s take a closer look at the pros and cons of full-finger vs. fingerless bike gloves!

Why Do Cycling Gloves Not Have Fingers?

First, it helps to understand why some bike gloves have cut-off fingers in the first place.

Fingerless cycling gloves first became popular many years ago among BMX riders and mountain bikers.

These extreme disciplines require excellent grip and control over the handlebars to perform tricks and navigate rough terrain.

Having exposed fingertips provides a better feel and dexterity on the brake levers and shifters.

It also allows the fingers to directly contact the bars for maximum control.

Fingerless gloves are ideal when you need fingertip protection but don’t want material bunching up between your fingers.

This original purpose of improving grip and feel is why fingerless cycling gloves are still common today among off-road riding disciplines.

However, many road cyclists have adopted them too for the increased comfort and ventilation they provide.

Are Bike Gloves Better With or Without Fingers?

So when it comes to choosing between full-finger or fingerless cycling gloves, which is better?

The truth is that it depends on your individual needs and preferences.

There are good reasons to go either way.

Let’s break it down:

Benefits of Full-Finger Cycling Gloves

  • More padding and protection for your entire hand
  • Insulation to keep hands warmer in cold weather
  • Prevent blisters and chafing on fingers and palms
  • Absorb shock and vibration from road impacts
  • Can be warmer and more comfortable overall

Benefits of Fingerless Cycling Gloves

  • Better grip and dexterity for shifting and braking
  • Allow fingers to directly contact the handlebar
  • Ventilation to keep hands cooler in warm weather
  • Easy to take on and off between rides
  • Stylish look that many cyclists prefer

As you can see, both full-finger and fingerless gloves have their advantages.

Full-finger gloves offer more coverage and padding for shock absorption.

Fingerless gloves provide a better feel and breathability.

Which is best will come down to the type of riding you do and your personal preferences.

Now let’s look at some key differences in more detail…

What’s the Difference Between Full-finger and Fingerless Cycling Gloves?

To decide whether you prefer full-finger or fingerless cycling gloves, here are some of the key differences to consider:

Coverage

The most obvious difference is that full-finger gloves cover your entire hand, including each finger individually.

Fingerless gloves have exposed fingertips and may just have a half-finger design.

Full-finger gloves will provide more insulation for cold conditions and protect the entire hand from elements.

Fingerless allows more airflow to keep hands cool when riding in warm weather.

Padding and Protection

Full-finger cycling gloves typically have more padding layers and reinforced panels across the palm and fingers.

This protects against blisters, absorbs vibration, and cushions your hands from impact.

Fingerless gloves focus padding on the palm but leave fingers with less shock absorption.

Grip and Dexterity

Fingerless cycling gloves allow your bare fingertips to directly grip brake levers and shift paddles.

This can provide a better “feel” and control over your bike’s components.

Full-finger gloves add a layer of material between fingers and bars which some cyclists feel reduces dexterity.

Breathability

Exposed fingers enable greater airflow which makes fingerless cycling gloves much more breathable in hot weather.

Full-finger gloves can lead to a sweaty feeling inside on long summer rides.

This moisture buildup can even cause slippage on the bars.

Cuff Length

Fingerless gloves typically have a shorter cuff that ends right above the wrists.

This further enhances airflow to the hands.

Full-finger cycling gloves need a longer cuff to seal out elements, so they extend further up the forearm.

Aesthetics

It’s also fair to say that fingerless cycling gloves have a certain cool factor and aesthetic appeal.

Many riders think they look more stylish and hardcore than full-finger gloves.

But ultimately comfort and performance should take priority over looks.

By understanding these key differences, you can better evaluate which glove style fits your needs as a cyclist.

Next, let’s look specifically at the benefits of going fingerless.

Are Fingerless Gloves Better for Biking?

For certain types of cycling, fingerless gloves can definitely be better than full-finger.

Here are some of the main advantages fingerless cycling gloves offer:

  • Enhanced Grip – With bare fingertips, you can grip brake levers and shifters with maximum control. The tactile feel of your fingers on the bars helps grip.
  • Cooling Effect – Exposed fingers allow more air circulation to keep hands cooler and drier when riding hard. Less overheating and sweat buildup.
  • Increased Dexterity – Less material between your fingers enables better feel and finesse when operating bike components. You’ll shift and brake with precision.
  • Quick Drying – Fingerless cycling gloves are easier to wash and air dry overnight after a ride. No finger compartments to trap moisture inside.
  • Easy On/Off – You can take fingerless gloves on and off as needed without a struggle. Convenient for stopping mid-ride to adjust gear or take a break.
  • Trendy Style – Many riders think fingerless cycling gloves simply look more stylish. Their minimalist and athletic look is popular among roadies and mountain bikers alike.

So if you’re a performance-minded cyclist riding in warm weather, need an excellent braking/shifting feel, or just want a stylish look – fingerless gloves could be the way to go.

They offer a great blend of ventilation, dexterity and grip.

Should I Get Fingerless Gloves or With Fingers?

By this point, you hopefully have a better understanding of the fingerless vs. full-finger cycling glove debate.

But you still may be wondering – which is right for me?

Here are my tips for deciding:

  • Road Biking – Fingerless offers better grip and airflow for long road rides.
    But full-finger provides more shock absorption if riding on rough pavement.
  • Mountain Biking – Fingerless allows better brake/shift control for technical terrain.
    But full-finger delivers more finger protection from scrapes if you crash.
  • Cold Weather – Definitely go full-finger in winter or cold temps.
    The coverage and insulation keeps hands warmer.
  • Hot Weather – Fingerless is the way to go on sweltering rides.
    The breathability keeps hands from overheating and sweating excessively.
  • Hand Problems – Those with hand pain or arthritis may prefer full-finger for extra cushioning and support. But fingerless allows you to better spread out pressure across fingers.
  • Bike Type – Fingerless pairs great with brake lever and shifters that require precise feel.
    But drop handlebars may benefit more from full-finger due to less grip positions.

My advice is to choose based on the weather conditions you ride in and the kind of bike handling your rides demand.

And don’t be afraid to own both varieties to use as needed! Having options for full-finger and fingerless is ideal for dedicated cyclists.

Final Thoughts

Hopefully, this breakdown has helped you gain clarity on the age-old cycling question – Are gloves better with or without fingers?

When chosen for the right reasons, I believe either can be a great option.

Key tips to remember:

  • Fingerless maximizes grip, dexterity, and airflow but minimizes padding.
  • Full-finger provides more shock absorption and weather protection but can sacrifice feel.
  • Consider weather, bike type, hand issues and riding style when deciding.
  • Many riders own both fingerless and full-finger gloves to use situationally.

Cycling gloves play a crucial role in every ride.

Protecting your hands from fatigue and injury enables more comfortable miles.

Keep experimenting to find your perfect pair!

Whether you go fingerless or full-finger, enjoy the two-wheeled journey. Ride on!

Avatar photo
Joey B. Ramsey
Passionate cyclist, father, and blogger.
I've been riding bikes since childhood and enjoy sharing my knowledge with fellow cycling enthusiasts.
My diverse bike collection allows me to write reviews and advice based on personal experience with various bikes and accessories.
join me email cta
Join me
Join me for more cycling related content and deals.

Related Articles