Best Bicycle Insurance in USA 2023

Best Bicycle Insurance in USA 2023

I’m pumped you’re here because choosing the right bicycle insurance can be tricky.

As an avid cyclist myself, I’ve made my fair share of mistakes when it comes to protecting my beloved bikes.

In this beginner’s guide, I’ll walk you through everything you need to know about bicycle insurance.

We’ll cover the basics like whether it’s worth it, the different benefits, and how much it costs.

By the end, you’ll be ready to find the perfect policy for your needs!

Strap on your helmet and let’s hit the road!

Is it Worth it to Get Bike Insurance?

Short answer: yes!

Bicycle insurance is absolutely worth it in my book.

The long answer? Well, it depends on a few factors:

How Much Your Bike is Worth – If you dropped thousands on a high-end road or mountain bike, insurance is a must.

Replacing it out of pocket would be brutal.

But for a cheaper around-town cruiser, the cost of insurance could outweigh replacing it.

How Often You Ride – Do you log serious miles day in and out? Or just ride recreationally on weekends?

The more time you spend on the bike, the higher the odds of an accident or theft.

More risk means insurance makes more sense.

Where You Typically Ride – Urban streets or remote backcountry trails?

Different locations present different dangers for your bike.

Assess the risks where you ride most.

Your Personal Risk Tolerance – Some cyclists don’t mind going naked.

Others want financial protection in case disaster strikes. Know which camp you fall into.

Personally, I ride a $5k carbon road bike for fitness and commute around a major city.

So I always keep it insured for peace of mind. But your situation may warrant a different choice.

Evaluate your specific riding profile and the value of your bike(s).

Weigh the cost of premiums against potential out-of-pocket expenses.

And don’t forget to check if your homeowners or renters insurance includes some degree of bike coverage too.

What Are the Benefits of Bicycle Insurance?

Okay, so bicycle insurance can be worth it – but what exactly are the benefits?

Here are some of the key perks:

1. Coverage for Theft

Getting your bike stolen sucks. Like, really bad.

Insurance softens the financial blow by reimbursing you for all or part of your bike’s value.

Rates of bike theft are on the rise nationwide, so protection is clutch.

2. Coverage for Damage

Accidents happen, especially with cycling.

Whether you wipe out on a muddy trail or get sideswiped by a car, insurance covers repairs or replacement costs associated with physical damage.

3. Liability Protection

If you cause damage to someone else’s property while riding, liability coverage pays for their losses.

It also covers legal expenses if you’re sued.

Vital protection if you share roads and paths.

4. Accessory Coverage

Your helmet, cycling computer, tools, bags…all the gear adds up!

Many policies cover attached accessories too.

Just double-check your limits.

5. Personal Injury Coverage

Pays your medical bills if you’re hurt in a covered accident.

Ideal if you have limited health insurance.

6. Zero Deductible Plans

Some policies waive your deductible if something happens during a sponsored event, like a charity ride. Sweet!

Obviously, the specifics vary between providers.

But in general, those are the key advantages bicycle insurance can offer.

Can You Get Insurance on a Mountain Bike?

For sure! Mountain bikes can absolutely be insured.

In fact, I especially recommend coverage if you have an expensive full-suspension trail or downhill rig.

Now, insuring a mountain bike has a few unique considerations:

  • Off-road Risks – Mountain biking carries more hazards that typical road riding.
    Expect higher premiums to match the elevated risks of hitting jumps and bombing downhill.
  • Remote Locations – Since many trail networks are far from civilization, claims could be harder to validate if something happens out in the sticks.
    Make sure to document your rides.
  • Damage Frequency – Riding rugged terrain can be punishing on your bike.
    Expect to file more frequent damage claims compared to road cycling.
  • Coverage Specifics – Double-check that your policy covers damage incurred off-road riding.
    Some are limited to paved surfaces.
  • Racer Exceptions – If you compete in downhill or enduro events, some insurers may exclude those activities or only cover you at additional cost.

The right mountain bike policy will account for the thrills and spills of riding singletrack.

Expect to pay around 10-20% more compared to road bike coverage.

But for pricey downhill bikes, the premium is absolutely worthwhile.

Can You Insure a Bicycle Against Theft?

Fear not urban riders – you can definitely insure your bicycle against theft!

Theft coverage is actually one of the primary benefits of most bike insurance policies.

Here’s an overview of how bicycle theft insurance works:

  • Police Report Required – If your bike gets stolen, you must file a police report to make a claim.
    Be sure to provide all identifying details.
    Serial number, photos, receipts etc.
  • Reimbursement Provided – With an approved claim, the insurer will reimburse you for all or a portion of your bike’s value per the policy limits.
    Payout timeframes vary.
  • Deductible Applies – As with damage claims, you’ll pay any applicable deductible.
    So theft coverage doesn’t fully eliminate out-of-pocket costs.
  • Prevention Discounts – Some insurers offer lower premiums if you use locks and theft-deterrent devices.
    Ask your agent for details.
  • Policy Limits – There are usually caps on reimbursement value, so high-end bikes may only have partial coverage.
    Read the fine print.

While no fun, having robust theft protection gives great peace of mind if you regularly park your bike on the streets.

Insure your bike when riding in urban areas.

How Much is Bicycle Insurance in the USA?

Alright, let’s get into the nitty gritty – how much does bike insurance actually cost?

The rates can vary quite a bit based on these factors:

Value of Your Bike – Premiums are primarily based on your bike’s replacement value.

Expect to pay more for high-end rides.

Coverage Selected – Higher liability limits, accessory coverage, etc. raise costs.

Strip down for basic theft/damage.

Deductible Amount – As with car insurance, choosing a lower deductible means a higher premium.

Your Location – Insurance pricing involves local risk assessment.

Urban areas cost more than suburbs or rural.

Your Riding History – Lots of past claims will bump your rates, similar to auto insurance increases after accidents.

Discounts – Take advantage of any multi-policy, security device, or affiliation discounts offered.

On average, I’d expect to budget $100-300 per year for basic theft and damage coverage on a mid-range bike worth $1000-2000.

High-end bikes can quickly jump up to $500+ per year.

Compare quotes from multiple insurers since rates for the same coverage can vary wildly.

And review discounts to keep your costs down.

To learn more, check out my article on how much is bicycle insurance.

How Do I Choose Bike Insurance?

Alright, we’ve covered the basics of bicycle insurance.

Now, how do you actually go about choosing the right policy?

Here’s my expert advice:

  1. Start with Homeowners/renters Insurance – There may be coverage built-in or available as an endorsement.
    Easy place to start.
  2. Review Policy Terms Closely – Don’t just look at premium cost.
    Check coverage limits, exclusions, deductibles, discounts, rating, etc.
  3. Match coverage to Your Needs – A racer needs more robust injury protection compared to a casual rider.
    Align it with how you ride.
  4. Consider an Independent Insurer – Specialty providers like Velosurance cater just to cyclists.
    Often better coverage than standard insurance.
  5. Compare Quotes – Rates vary a lot company to company.
    Get quotes from at least 3-5 providers before deciding.
  6. Ask About Group Discounts – Many bike shops and clubs partner with insurers for member discounts.
    Could be a cost saver!
  7. Read Online Reviews – Check what existing customers say about the claims process and customer service.
  8. Consider Value-adds – Some insurers offer perks like free tune-ups, discounts at bike retailers, and ride-tracking apps.
  9. Confirm Financial Strength – Only use insurers with strong financial ratings, like A.M. Best A or A+.

Take your time and find the perfect blend of affordable pricing and protection that fits your cycling lifestyle.

Don’t settle for bare-bones coverage that will leave you high and dry!

Best Bicycle Insurance in USA 2023

Looking for my top recommended bicycle insurers for 2023?

Here are the best options for affordable, comprehensive coverage:


Still my favorite for its all-around value and cycling-specific perks.

Velosurance policies start at around $100-150 per year for basic theft/damage coverage on a mainstream bike.

Premium road bikes can run $300+ annually.

Most plans come with $100-500 deductibles.

They offer robust coverage options like $1 million liability protection, full replacement reimbursement, and worldwide coverage.

Velosurance really stands out for its policy extras like free tune-ups, shop discounts, and personalized claims service.

Top-notch for cyclists.


Markel shines for its flexible, build-your-own coverage with deductibles starting at $50.

Base rates run $120-180 yearly.

Markel policies can extend up to $50k total coverage value.

While max liability is lower at $300k, you can add medical and injury benefits. Accessory and custom parts coverage is excellent.

Overall, Markel is great for customizing protection if Velosurance’s pre-set packages aren’t quite right.

State Farm

The insurance giant offers solid bike insurance for $50-150 per year bundled with existing home or auto policies.

Coverage limits top out around $2,500 and deductibles sit around $100-$250.

Extra liability insurance is available.

State Farm plans aren’t as robust for hardcore cycling enthusiasts, but offer a convenient add-on for current customers.


Known for auto, Progressive bike plans cost $100-250 annually with deductibles of $100-$500.

They cover up to $5k in damage/theft and $500k liability.

Perks like diminishing deductibles over claim-free years make their rates competitive.

Overall, a nice mainstream option for bike/home bundling.


Similar to State Farm and Progressive, Allstate bike insurance runs $150-300 per year bundled with other policies.

They offer accident medical coverage and higher liability limits starting at $250k.

Deductibles range from $100-$500.

Allstate insures bikes up to $15k value, so solid for high-end rides.

Their coverage isn’t cycling-specific but provides solid protection add-ons.

Final Thoughts

Well, there you have it folks – everything you need to know to find fantastic bicycle insurance!

I hope this beginner’s guide shed some light on why bike insurance is important, how it works, and who offers the best policies.

Protecting your two-wheeled freedom machine is always a smart call.

Whatever your cycling style, there’s an affordable insurance policy that fits.

Now grab your helmet and get back to the open road with peace of mind!

Ride on my friends!

Let me know if you have any other bike insurance questions. I’m always happy to help a fellow cycling enthusiast get set up with protection.

Stay safe out there!

Avatar photo
Joey B. Ramsey
Passionate cyclist, father, and blogger.
I've been riding bikes since childhood and enjoy sharing my knowledge with fellow cycling enthusiasts.
My diverse bike collection allows me to write reviews and advice based on personal experience with various bikes and accessories.
join me email cta
Join me
Join me for more cycling related content and deals.

Related Articles